The read-along continues with the second part of N.K. Jemisin's The Kingdom of Gods! This week, the questions were provided by Violin in a Void, and they cover up through chapter 10. Beware of spoilers below!
1.
Do you think Shahar can keep her childhood promise and be a good person and an
Arameri?
I
suppose that depends on how strict one keeps the definition of a “good
person”. She is not without
compassion, but she is shaping up to how her family operates. For instance, she was going to threaten
genocide to get her way, until Sieh shamed her out of it. She argues she would never actually do
it, but using that as a threat is pretty serious.
Also,
her betrayal of Sieh was just a disaster.
She must have suspected that bearing his child would kill him, based on
their earlier discussions of childhood. When she told Sieh, I’m not sure what
she expected to accomplish; maybe it was just a failed attempt to do the right
thing. Sieh himself seemed to believe it was a ploy to get him to kill her
mother, at least until Shahar nearly sacrificed herself to save her.
Right
now, I guess, she’s mostly just young, inexperienced and doesn’t always seem to think through the
consequences of her actions. She
has a lot of negative influences and not many positive, so I’m not sure if
she’ll be able to keep that from affecting her.
2.
The Arameri family has changed drastically and now we learn they're being
systematically killed off. Do you like the changes? Do you feel sorry for the
family or are they getting what they deserve?
I
didn’t really notice this in the first section, but it makes sense that so much
would have changed. They’ve lost the Enefadeh, and they’ve made a lot of
enemies over the years. I would
hesitate to say they’re getting what they deserve, though. They may be getting what their
ancestors deserve, but it’s starting to look like the modern-day Arameri are
not exactly like their ancestors.
I guess that means I like the changes, and I don’t think the whole
family deserves to die based solely on their legacy.
3.
Any theories on the antagonist that Sieh meets in his dream?
Right
now, my wild theory is that it is Dekarta. We know that Dekarta surprisingly and luckily had magical
talent that was discovered shortly after their disastrous declaration of
friendship. Could it be possible
that when Sieh became part mortal, Deka became part god? Maybe the other Arameri don’t even
realize it. If so, his existence
could now be linked to Sieh in some way.
4.
Religious belief in the city and the palace has changed a lot, as have humans'
relationships with the gods. Thoughts? What might your beliefs be if you lived
in Sky/Shadow?
I
think the Primortalist’s beliefs make sense. The gods in this world clearly exist, but they just as
clearly don’t always have the best interests of their mortal followers at
heart.
5.
Sieh's not quite the charming boy god we saw in book 1. How do you feel about
his character at the moment?
I
think he is probably not all that different in temperament than he was in the
first book. He had been killing
Arameri here and there the whole time he was enslaved, so that’s not exactly
new. He also doesn’t think about
consequences, acts on impulse, and is still very easy to set off. Yeine saw a very different side of him,
but that doesn’t mean this side didn’t exist, then, too. I think he’s a really interesting protagonist, but he's not someone I would ever want to meet!
6.
Should Sieh work for Ahad?
I
think Ahad was right about his potential as a courtesan, so a resounding ‘no’
in that sense. I think he should
work for Ahad in some way, though, and stick around. It looks like his relationship with Ahad could teach him a
lot about his relationships with Shahar and Itempas. I hope that he and Ahad can come through the wrong Sieh did
to him to some kind of understanding, and that will help him figure out how to
deal with the other people in his life.
I
was a little confused about what happened when Sieh and Ahad merged. If I understood correctly, Ahad was not
Sieh’s biological son. I think that the problem was that Ahad thought of Sieh
as a father, since Sieh kind of raised him. Maybe it was made worse because Sieh had corresponding
fatherly feelings? In any case, it
was nice of Ahad to reinforce that they were brothers, to keep Sieh safe.
1. I think the way Shahar used genocide as a threat is a good indicator of what a messed up, elitist family the Arameri are. She seems to think she's a decent person simply because she wouldn't actually do it and doesn't realise how horrible it is to threaten people with genocide until Sieh calls her on it. I think it'll be hard for her to break the mould, not only because her family tries to force her to behave a certain way, but because she's been raised with an Arameri mindset.
ReplyDelete3. Interesting idea, I've been wondering if that'd be possible for Dekarta too. Also a bit suspicious that no one's seen him in ages.
5. Hehe, yeah, Sieh's a bit too unpredictable for my tastes too. He might just throw a tantrum and decide to kill you.
6. That's how I understand Sieh and Ahad's relationship too. They had something that resembled a father/son relationship but it's actually dangerous for Sieh to think of it as such. Nevertheless, I think it took its toll on him .
1. Yeah, her idea of what 'decent' means is probably affected by having grown up as an Arameri in Sky. I still hope she'll be able to find a way to break out of her upbringing.
ReplyDeleteI've already read the next section now, so I'll avoid commenting further on Ahad and Dekarta :).
Good point about Shahar being young and inexperienced, not fully aware of the consequences. She is making mistakes while trying to make it all better, all right, all good.
ReplyDeleteWeird! That would be an interesting plot twist if the stranger was Deka, having been turned part immortal when Sieh was turned part mortal. And no one at Sky really knows what his magical abilities are.
In Book 1, Sieh definitely wanted something from Yeine. Well, a few things - freedom, his mom, etc. But he saw part of Enefa in Yeine and I think that if Sieh was going to behave for anyone, it would be her. So, maybe part manipulation, and maybe part natural inclination.
That's true. He loved Yeine, so it makes sense he would tend to be nice towards her naturally, too.
Delete